Elementarydoes several things differently to the BBC’sSherlock, but it definitely avoids repeating the British show’s mistake when it comes to Moriarty. FollowingElementary’s season 7 cancellation, many new viewers are only just discovering the Sherlock Holmes adaptation. InElementary, Lucy Liu’s Watson isn’t the only character whose gender differs from the source material, as Moriarty is played by the incredible Natalie Dormer.
Dormer features in many ofElementary’s best episodesas Moriarty. However, it’s worth noting thatElementary’s execution of the character is nothing likeSherlock’s. While both versions of the character are intriguing and worth investing in,Elementarydoesn’t fail the character of Moriarty in the same way BBCSherlockdoes.
Unlike Sherlock, Elementary Never Became Too Dependent On Moriarty
Elementary Knew When To Give Moriarty A Break
Seeing as howthe earlier seasons ofElementaryare considered too similar toSherlock,it’s a surprise how differently the show approaches the villain Moriarty.Elementary’s take on the character of Moriarty is rather unique in comparison to otherSherlock Holmes TV adaptations. InElementary, the character is portrayed by Natalie Dormer, one ofthe best versions of Moriarty in Sherlock Holmes titles. However, it’s not just the fact that she is female in this adaptation that makes her unique — this Moriarty is also Irene Adler.
Despite Dormer playing not one, but two major characters inElementary, the show doesn’t overly rely on Moriarty, either.Andrew Scott’s take on Moriarty in the BBC’sSherlockis stellar,and he’s clearly born to play the role, but the show brings him back out time and time again.Sherlockis one ofScott’s best TV shows, but even when his character is dead, he’s still somehow the mastermind of every operation.
Elementary’s Jamie Moriarty Was A Fresh New Take On The Sherlock Villain
Natalie Dormer’s Interpretation Of The Character Is Unique In Comparison
While Jamie Moriarty/Irene Adler is Sherlock’s ex-lover, it’s not the only thing that matters about the character.ElementaryavoidsSherlock’s Moriarty problem by making her more subdued yet still mysterious,andnot as in-your-face evil as most versions of the character. She also comes and goes, rather than somehow ending up at the forefront of every major story arc. Plus, the fact that Adler and Moriarty are the same person is a refreshing change of pace for a Sherlock Holmes story.
Jamie Moriarty dominates every scene she appears in, andit’s clear that Natalie Dormer is having fun with the part.She sets her sights on Sherlock after he foils several of her plans while he’s at Scotland Yard, tricks him into falling in love with her, and causes chaos.
The Moriarty in the underrated Sherlock Holmes adaptation is somehow more unpredictable than her BBC counterpart.
She even continues to have an impact on him while in prison, andSherlock writes Moriarty letters while she’s incarcerated,which is a great way to keep the character relevant while also not overusing her. The Moriarty in theunderrated Sherlock Holmes adaptationis somehow more unpredictable than her BBC counterpart, which is really saying something.
Sherlock Relied Way Too Much On Moriarty And Couldn’t Move On From Him
The BBC Show Didn’t Know How To Use Other Villains
While I love BBC’sSherlock, I can also see the faults in the show, and the biggest one is that it can’t let go of Moriarty. I understand that Scott is a fantastic actor, and his portrayal of Moriarty is one of the very best ever, but this doesn’t excuse the factSherlockfails to think outside the box, villain-wise.Even when the show tries to introduce new antagonists, like Eurus Holmes or Charles Augustus Magnussen, Moriarty is always the mastermind inall 4 seasons ofSherlock.
That’s what’s so fascinating about Dormer’s Moriarty inElementary. Yes, her main focus is the titular character and their game of cat-and-mouse, but there is more to her life than just the detective.Sherlockkills off Moriarty in “The Reichenbach Fall,”which is in season 2, yet he continues to be the “big bad” right up until the very end.Moriarty’s videos from beyond the grave are a step too far,especially when it turns out he hasn’t faked his suicide, something many viewers anticipate during their first watch-through.
Elementary
Cast
A modern retelling of Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories, Elementary is set in New York City and details the adventures of Dr. Joan Watson (Lucy Liu) who becomes partner to the consulting detective Sherlock Holmes (Johnny Lee Miller) after first being assigned as his sober companion. Set up a procedural crime drama, the series includes multiple references to the original Holmes stories, often with surprising twists. Aidan Quinn and John Micahel Hill also star as Thomas Gregson and Marcus Bell, with John Noble as a notable guest star.
Sherlock
In this incarnation of Sherlock from creators Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman assume the roles of Sherlock and Watson as they establish their partnership and begin solving strange mysteries throughout the U.K. and beyond. Set in a more 2010’s modern setting, Sherlock’s eccentric and complex nature is accentuated as he solves seemingly supernatural crimes with unparalleled intellect while struggling to connect with others on a human level. Meanwhile, Watson blogs the stories summarizing their cases while building a strained but caring friendship with his new partner.
