Clint Eastwood rejected the script forDirty HarrywannabeMcQ- only for John Wayne to snap it up. Many screen icons were considered for the titular role inDirty Harry, including Paul Newman, Frank Sinatra and John Wayne. They all rejected it for one reason or another, be it the violence involved or perceived political incorrectness. Of course, it was the film that cemented eventual lead Clint Eastwood as an A-list star, and Harry remains one of his most famous characters; Eastwood later reprised the role for another fourDirty Harrymovies.
The film’s rogue main character and pushing of boundaries led to other projects trying to recapture the same lightning. One key example would be 1974’sDeath Wishstarring Charles Bronson, which was arguably evenmorecontroversial. Two more instances includeMcQandBrannigan, both of which starred John Wayne. Both thrillers cast Wayne as tough detectives who carry Magnum revolvers and bend the rules to see justice done. In short,John Wayne fronted twoDirty Harryripoffsafter passing on the original a few years prior.
Clint Eastwood Rejected The Dirty Harry Imitation McQ Before John Wayne Took It
Eastwood didn’t sound impressed with John Wayne’s McQ
While being interviewed by journalist Paul Nelson (viaConversations with Clint: Paul Nelson’s Lost Interviews with Clint Eastwood, 1979-1983), Eastwood was asked several questions about Wayne and his thoughts on the screen icon’s final film,The Shootist. This led Nelson to label Wayne’s “imitation Dirty Harry” as plain “embarrassing.” Presumably passing judgment on bothMcQandBrannigan, Eastwood replied:
I know. In fact, one of them was originally written for me: McQ. I passed on it.
Much has been made of a supposed feud between Eastwood and Wayne, though the latter once told Clint, “We ought to do a movie, kid,” as his career was taking off. By this point, Clint had become the face of a darker, more violent and cynical breed of Western, right as the genre’s popularity was waning.Wayne rejectingDirty Harryand it becoming a smash for his young rival is one thing, but Wayne accepting imitations of the film that Eastwood passed on is another. This signals how Wayne felt he missed the boat the first time out.
Of course, it was wise for Eastwood to turn down another rogue cop movie likeMcQ, since he had already signed on forDirty HarrysequelMagnum Force. Still,Wayne’sDirty Harryripoffs felt like pale xeroxes of Eastwood’s thriller, and if nothing else, confirmed that “The Duke” was wrong for the role anyway. The movies themselves are cliché detective thrillers that lackDirty Harry’sedge, though they at least stage some effective setpieces.
Why John Wayne Fronted Two “Embarassing” Dirty Harry Ripoffs After Rejecting The Original
Frank Sinatra was the problem
Dirty Harryis a screenplay that traveled around before it landed on Eastwood’s desk. The title character was intended to be older than Clint was at the time, which is why Hollywood vets like Paul Newman or Frank Sinatra got first dibs. In fact,Sinatra had accepted the role and was set to makeDirty Harry(under the working titleDead Right) before he bowed out, as he needed an operation on his wrist. Wayne wasn’t too pleased that he was approached about the roleafterSinatra exited, either.
According toJohn Wayne: The Man Behind the Myth, Wayne said, “I didn’t like being offered Sinatra’s rejections." During this period, Wayne was largely sticking to Westerns, having recently won an Academy Award forTrue Grit. Many of his follow-ups, likeRio Lobo(the final film of movie legend Howard Hawks) andCahill, U.S. Marshal, played like tired retreads of movies he had made many times before. Something likeDirty Harrycould have reinvigorated Wayne’s image with younger audiences.
… Wayne publicly stated his regret at passing on Dirty Harry, feeling it was an updating of the kind of Western characters he had played before.
Even so, it would have been a different film with Wayne as Harry. His distaste for bloody screen violence or vulgarity would have seen those elements toned down, for example. Still, Wayne publicly stated his regret at passing onDirty Harry, feeling it was an updating of the kind of Western characters he had played before. That’s what attracted him to projects likeMcQandBrannigan, but accepting lesser versions only proved to be another mistake.
Source: Conversations with Clint: Paul Nelson’s Lost Interviews with Clint Eastwood, 1979-1983, John Wayne: The Man Behind the Myth
Dirty Harry
Cast
Clint Eastwood stars in the western Dirty Harry as a no-nonsense San Francisco cop who takes the law into his own hands in pursuit of a serial killer, Scorpio. Directed by Don Siegel and featuring a memorable score by Lalo Schifrin, the film is known for its iconic catchphrases and intense action scenes, and has influenced countless films and TV shows in the years since its release.
McQ
McQ (1974) is a crime drama featuring John Wayne as a tough police lieutenant in Seattle who takes matters into his own hands to investigate the murder of his partner, navigating corruption and violence within the police force and the criminal underworld.
