Buffy the Vampire Slayeris an endlessly rewatchable show with iconic moments, sharp writing, and a cast of beloved characters. However, while it remains a genre-defining series, the truth is that its later seasons never quite captured the spark that made the early years so special. Something changed. and not for the better.
Many fans point to season 5 or 6 as the momentBuffy the Vampire Slayerstarted to lose its way. For some, the blame lands squarely onthe introduction of Dawn,Buffy’s surprise sister who seemingly came out of nowhere. However, while her arrival was jarring, Dawn wasn’t the problem.
After rewatchingBuffy the Vampire Slayer, it’s clear the show’s tonal shift began in season 6,butDawn had little to do with that. Instead, a major creative decision at the start of the season marked a change in direction that never quite worked. The storytelling got darker, and not always in a way that felt true to the show’s heart. There’s no denyingBuffystarted slipping in later seasons, and one moment stands out as the start of the decline.
Buffy Being Pulled Out Of Heaven Set The Tone For A Way Too Dark Season 6
Season 6 Opened With A Brilliant Concept That Unfortunately Sent The Show Spiraling Into Bleak Territory
Buffy the Vampire Slayerseason 5ended on a cliffhanger.Buffy sacrificed herself to save Dawn, delivering a heartfelt goodbye as she dove into a portal to stop a hellish apocalypse. However, rather than leaving her resting in peace or finding a different path forward, season 6 brought Buffy back from the dead - and not in a triumphant or thrilling way.
Willow, Xander, Anya, and Tara used dark magic to resurrect Buffy. What they didn’t know was that she hadn’t been trapped in hell, and they weren’t rescuing her from eternal torment. As Buffy revealed in season 6, episode 3, “After Life”,she had been in heaven.
The tone shift felt like a gut punch to the show’s usual balance of humor, horror, and heart.
This twist set up a fascinating idea, but the fallout was devastating. Buffy spent most of the seasonin a deep, numb depression, unable to reconnect with her old life. She felt alienated, detached, and lost. WhileSarah Michelle Gellar deliveredsome of her finest work, the tone shift felt like a gut punch to the show’s usual balance of humor, horror, and heart.
Buffy the Vampire Slayerhad always tackled dark subject matter, but it usually countered that with levity and charm. Season 6 leaned hard into emotional trauma, addiction, and nihilism. It wasn’t just a darker season -it felt like an entirely different show. From Buffy’s deteriorating mental health to Willow’s descent into magic addiction, everything was bleak.
The show’s signature mix of genre fun and emotional growth was still present, but buried under layers of pain.Themusical episode “Once More, With Feeling”remains a highlight, but it only underscores how out of place much of the season felt. The resurrection storyline cast a long shadow, andBuffy the Vampire Slayernever quite emerged from it.
Buffy Still Needed To Come Back, But It Should Have Been In A Different Way
Buffy’s Return Was Necessary, But The Execution Missed What Made Her Journey Inspiring
Asmuch as seeing Buffy diein a moment of selfless sacrifice was a satisfying narrative ending,Buffy the Vampire Slayersimply couldn’t go on without its central character. The show’s emotional core and moral compass was always Buffy, and Sarah Michelle Gellar’s performance grounded even the most fantastical plots in relatable humanity. Her return was inevitable, but the way it happened didn’t serve her story.
Buffy had already died once in the season 1 finale, “Prophecy Girl.” That moment was dramatic and earned, but also resolved with a triumphant resurrection that led to character growth. Season 6’s revival was the opposite. Itstripped Buffy of hopeand weighed her down with existential despair. After fighting so hard for peace, she finally found it, only to have it cruelly taken away.
There was very little narrative justification for putting Buffy through that kind of suffering.
There was very little narrative justification for putting Buffy through that kind of suffering. While the show wanted to explore the consequences of meddling with life and death, itdidn’t give Buffy much of a path forward.Instead, she wandered through the season haunted, aimless, and deeply broken.Even her bond with Dawn, the sister she died to protect, felt strained.
Buffy the Vampire Slayerhad always found clever ways to reinvent itself, but this time it leaned too far into tragedy. Buffy being pulled from heaven wasn’t just sad -it felt cruel.The writers may have wanted to depict the real cost of trauma, but it clashed with the empowering themes the series was built on. Buffy wasn’t inspired by her second resurrection; she was shattered by it.
A more hopeful take could have still addressed death, grief, and darkness, but in a way that let Buffy reclaim her strength. Instead, her returning from the deadin season 6 left Buffy- and the audience - adrift in gloom. Bringing her back was essential, but it should have honored the hero she had become, not punished her for it.
The Show Tried To Rebound After Season 6, But Never Recaptured Its Early Brilliance
By the timeBuffy the Vampire Slayerreached season 7, the damage had already been done. Though there was a clear attempt to recenter the show and deliver a conclusive arc, the spark that defined its early seasons had mostly flickered out. The sense of momentum was gone, and the characters (especially Buffy) felt emotionally depleted.
Buffy’strauma from being pulled out of heaven continuedto echo into season 7, making it hard for her to ever fully return to the lighter, more charismatic version of herself. Her leadership of the Potential Slayers was a promising concept, but the execution was uneven. Episodes like “Conversations with Dead People” had flashes of brilliance, but they were exceptions.
Buffy deserved better - and so did her audience.
Buffy the Vampire Slayeralso struggled to give its supporting cast compelling arcs.Xander faded into the background, Dawn remained underused, and Willow’s magic addiction was glossed over in a way that felt unearned. Meanwhile, the season’s Big Bad, the First Evil, lacked the presence and impact of past villains like Glory or the Mayor.
Most importantly, the series finale, “Chosen,” while emotionally satisfying in parts, didn’t carry the same emotional weight as earlier season-enders. It wrapped things up, but the sense of finality felt rushed. Buffy’s big speech to the Potentials was meant to be empowering, butlacked the emotional build-up it needed to truly land.
97%
88%
92%
96%
100%
78%
91%
83%
95%
67%
89%
82%
Buffy the Vampire Slayerwill always be remembered as a groundbreaking series, but its final season didn’t live up to the best of what came before. The show never fully bounced back from the tonal nosedive in season 6, and the finale felt like a quiet goodbye rather than a victorious conclusion.Buffy deserved better- and so did her audience.
